For those of us up here in the Green Mountains, we’re finally just starting to find Spring popping up all around. While today’s blustery winds brought a mix of snow and rain and there are still small heaps of ice and snow coating the wetlands behind my house, the flocks of birds at the bird feeder and blooming crocuses in my front yard let me know the end is near.
We had a long winter this year and some unusual thaw and freeze patterns. That mixed with the recent floods and thunderstorms has done some real damage to my most trekked trail along the Mad River. While I was sad to see the downed limbs, broken branches and layers of debris spread along the almost-washed-out path, I couldn’t fight back the urge to come out of my cocoon and get my butt back outside! It’s not surprising that it was just about a year ago when I started barefoot running. Today, I received my second pair of Vibram’s in the mail. It’s true, I’m hooked. This time I picked up a shiny pair of the new Vibram Fivefingers Treksports.
My KSO’s are holding up beautifully, despite all the running, swimming and hiking I put them through last year. However, there were several reasons why the Treksports lured me in. I recently started working with a personal trainer. Naturally, I brought my KSO’s with me. The first day, I took her spinning class prior to my personal training intake and I immediately regretted my decision. The pedal of the bike I was on rode right on my arches, the softest most vulnerable part of the foot (aside from, perhaps, in between the toes). I was visibly in pain, My trainer moved me to another bike with a wider pedal, which helped, but overall I found the KSOs were just not the right choice.
My main reason for seeking personal training right now is that I have some big plans in mind for my summer. Now that the weather is warming up I’m just itching to be outdoors as much as possible and I really want to push myself this year. Running was fun, but I’m not necessarily looking to run as much this year. I’m thinking of trying climbing and taking on more adventurous hikes. I also need a shoe that can continue to play with me while I kayak, canoe, and splash around in Vermont’s rivers and lakes.
While the KSO’s did a fine job of keeping up with my water-bound activities last year, the Treksport’s plated midsoles and lightly cleated outsole really appealed to me. I never fully felt comfortable using my KSO’s on adventurous hikes because of those few moments of stabbing pain on my arches when I hit a rock at the wrong angle, and the fact that I slipped quite a bit in mud. For running, they were perfect. For hiking, they just weren’t beefy enough. However, the kangaroo leather upper on the KSO Treks didn’t jive well with my love for water or my being slightly put-off by wearing kangaroo hide on my feet.
So, on to the part you’re probably most interested in: a picture comparison. Disclaimer: keep in mind my KSOs are a bit worn.
The first time I slipped the Treksports on I definitely felt they had more continuity, but I still felt a firm connection with the ground and easy articulation. My first test was to wrap my arches around a pointy piece of wood and the plated arch definitely works! More on that later.
Let’s start by talking about the posterior difference:
As you can see, the Treksport have some padding around the Achilles. This triangle-shaped pillow rises from the heel and makes the heel look wider than the KSOs in this picture, but when worn it hugs the heel nicely and provides additional stability. Both feature the same strap design and both have a loop on the rear.
While I haven’t experienced this with my KSOs, several folks online have complained that their non-reinforced toe Fivefinger shoes show signs of wear and ripping on the tops of the toes. In the champagne color Treksports, the reinforced toes are clear and shiny. I’ve read other reviews that the dark colored models have black reinforcing. Regardless of the color, this is an important feature for those of us who really want to put our Vibrams through its paces.
Laterally, there isn’t a huge difference between the KSO and the Treksport with the exception that the Treksport sits a bit higher on its cleated sole. It also appears that the outside rubber comes up just a hair higher on the Treksport.
Medially, there’s a noticeable difference between the two. The KSOs actually have greater coverage on the medial part of the sole which causes the Treksport to appear to curve more at the arch. While I haven’t played around with these enough to know yet, it does appear that the Treksports have more arch support whereas the KSOs are fairly flat with just a mild curve for the arch.
Now here’s the real money shot:
Oh, let’s see that up close!
The biggest visible difference between the KSO and the Treksport is the sole. While my KSOs are a bit worn, the texture on the bottom of the KSOs are minimal. The Treksport has noticeable grooves and mild cleats to provide better traction and grip in various terrain. I’ll be honest, I wouldn’t want the Treksport if I was new to barefoot running. “Real” barefoot runners already poo-poo us Fivefinger folks, and the Treksports push that line further. Yes, it’s still much less padding than a sneaker and one can certainly run in them, but it wouldn’t be my choice.
However, with the additional grip and the reinforced arch I will definitely feel more comfortable trying the Treksports out in environments I shied away from with my KSOs. One other thing to note is that the midsole is much thinner on the Treksport. I have narrow feet and after walking around in these for a while I felt no discomfort or insecurities. If you have wide feet you might want to really try them out in a store before making the investment. I’ve only read positive reviews on the midsole width so far, but it’s something to take note of.
I’m super-stoked to take my new Fivefingers out for a ride! Now that I’ve come out of winter hibernation, expect to hear more of my Treksport adventures! Let’s hope they can keep up with me. 😉
Oh, and for those of you who are only here for the dog stories, here’s Toby and his new buddy, Charlie, enjoying some VT April showers. Seriously, this white death falling from the sky has got to stop!